Revue de Didactique, Linguistique et Traduction
Volume 4, Numéro 1, Pages 151-165
2026-06-30
Authors : Bocoum Boubacar . Kuma Amma Gyaama . Boamah-boateng Dennis .
Cratylus has often led to two observations: first, the dialogue astonishingly holds a neutral philosophical stance regarding the origins of meaning; second, despite its age, the work is still relevant to debates in the philosophy of language (Demos, 1964: 595). This paper maintains that the methodological neutrality and rich etymological discussion found in Cratylus enhance both its productivity and relevance. By confronting the antagonistic theories of naturalism and conventionalism, the study examines Socratic interventions that wisely critique and advocate aspects of each theory. Using a mixed-methods approach, the paper integrates a textual analysis and a comparative corpus analysis of 200 expressions from 10 languages. The findings confirm that Cratylus is indeed significantly neutral as conventionalism can be challenged by kinship terminology while naturalism has shown some limitations with the analysis of onomatopoeic expressions. Not settling the debate about the correctness of names makes Cratylus methodologically productive and historically reliable.
Plato ; Philosophy of Language ; Meaning ; Naturalism ; Conventionalism
شامي ر
.
ص 42-62.
قاضي الشيخ
.
ص 976-996.